Thanksgiving pie preorders are open — order by Mon, Nov 23 · pick up Nov 24–25

The Magpie Bakery · Bloomingdale, NJ

Pies worth gathering for

From-scratch pies, pastries, and good coffee at Riverside Square. Thanksgiving preorders are open — your dessert table, handled.

Order Thanksgiving pies See the pies
Open today · 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM · (973) 291-6756

How a Magpie pie happens

Butter crust, rolled by hand

Every pie starts the same way it has for thirty years — flour, butter, patience.

Fruit piled high, lattice laid strip by strip

No shortcuts, no freezer case. Just the good stuff, woven shut.

Baked Thursday-worthy. Boxed for your table.

Order online, pick it up at Riverside Square, take the credit at dinner.

The pie line

Order without the phone tag

Melanie's hands are in the dough — the pie line isn't. It takes your order any hour, and she bakes it fresh for your pickup day.

💬

Order by chat

Tap the pie button in the corner. Pick your pies, pick your day — your order lands straight on the bakery counter.

📞

Order by phone

Call the pie line and the ordering assistant answers — even when the ovens are full.

Number coming soon

From the case

Find your favorite pie

Browse the pies, then choose pickup options on each one. The full bakery & café menu — pastries, hand pies, donuts, coffee — is just as serious.

Illustration: a slice of blueberry pie
FruitBlueberry Pie$27.95
CreamBanana Cream Pie$26.95
CrumbCherry Crumb Pie$27.95
CrumbApple Blueberry Crumb$26.95
CustardCoconut Custard Cream$26.95
CreamChocolate Cream Pie$26.95
FruitCherry Pie$27.95
FruitStrawberry Rhubarb$27.95

Thanksgiving pie preorders

Your dessert table, handled

Illustration: a lattice pie on a Thanksgiving table
1

Order by Mon, Nov 23

Add pies to your cart online and choose a pickup date on each pie.

2

Pick up Nov 24–25

Swing by Riverside Square on the Tuesday or Wednesday before Thanksgiving.

3

Take the credit

Warm it, serve it, accept the compliments. We won't tell.

Order Thanksgiving pies →
Illustration: the Magpie's pastry case, with a magpie perched on the counter

Meet the baker

“A magpie collects bright little treasures. The bakery is built in that spirit — a case full of small, shiny, worth-collecting things, gathered fresh each morning.”

Visit us

Find the Magpie

The Magpie Bakery & Café
2-14 Riverside Square
Bloomingdale, NJ 07403

(973) 291-6756
mel@magpiebakery.com

Get directions
Monday8:00 – 3:00
Tuesday8:00 – 5:00
Wednesday8:00 – 5:00
Thursday8:00 – 5:00
Friday8:00 – 5:00
Saturday8:00 – 5:00
Sunday8:00 – 3:00

Regular hours — around holidays, call before you visit.